Forward into the Past Via VIA

The San Antonio urban area has about 1.9 million people today and, if it keeps growing at recent rates, will add 1.6 million more by 2040. VIA, the region’s transit agency, gets most of its money from a one-half-cent sales tax, so by 2040 it will get about 80 percent more tax revenues.


Click image to download this 40-MB PDF.

The agency is hungry for more, however, so it has written a long-range plan called Vision 2040. Actually, to call this a plan is generous; it is actually more of a sales brochure, as it doesn’t consider any alternatives, any impacts of the proposal, or any real information about costs. Instead, it merely says that it wants increased taxes to provide bus-rapid transit on exclusive bus lanes and possibly light rail–in other words, transit infrastructure that might have been useful a few decades ago, but certainly won’t be useful a few decades from now.

tadalafil best prices http://appalachianmagazine.com/2015/10/19/the-incredible-story-of-the-blue-ridge-parkway/ The difference between passive, assertive, angry and the most dangerous of all – passive aggressive. The hard on attained will reverse back after the sexual act, the blood goes out of the penis as the stimulation ends. pop over here the cost of viagra As the name says, you can strap this toy around your waist and enter the man from the effect of impotency. order cialis http://appalachianmagazine.com/2019/12/11/small-earthquake-shakes-new-river-valley-roanoke-early-tuesday-third-in-week/ the effective output of qualitative study and research to treat impotency introduced in market by the joint venture of Eli Lilly &Company and by ICOS Corporation. This plentiful amount of blood when collected near that area, the organ becomes blood-filled and hard enough for penetration. viagra usa pharmacy Comments on the vision are due tomorrow, and you can download the Antiplanner’s comments today. In a nutshell, the Antiplanner pointed out that transit is practically irrelevant in San Antonio today and will probably be completely irrelevant by 2040.

Transit currently carries less than 1 percent of San Antonio-area motorized passenger travel (and virtually no freight). Just 2.7 percent of commuters take transit to work. While a little more than 3 percent of San Antonio workers live in households with no cars, only 35 percent of those carless workers take transit to work, while 43 percent go by automobile. VIA buses carry an average of 8.6 riders over the course of a day, 18 percent less than the national average and well below Los Angeles Metro (20), San Francisco Muni (19), and New York MTA (18).

Meanwhile, Ford says it will have “fleets” of completely self-driving cars–no steering wheels, brakes, or accelerators–on the road by 2021. Even if that is optimistic, it is clear that self-driving cars will thoroughly transform urban transportation by 2040. Yet, except to half-heartedly allude to the possibility of self-driving buses, VIA’s 2040 plan doesn’t acknowledge the effects of this new technology on public transit. VIA spends more than twice as much to move someone a mile as it costs to drive a car one mile, so when shared, self-driving cars are available, why would anyone need VIA buses?

San Antonio is simply not built for public transit today and it will be even less suited for it in 2040. Thus, it makes no sense for the region’s taxpayers to spend a lot of money on exclusive bus lanes, especially considering those lanes will make congestion worse for everyone else, either by taking lanes from general traffic, giving signal priority to transit, or both.

VIA should probably do some low-cost experiments with bus-rapid transit, but on lanes shared with other vehicles and without giving signal priority to the buses. VIA should be able to do this without a tax increase. Expensive new infrastructure that will only be obsolete in a few years, if it isn’t already, makes no sense at all.

Tagged , . Bookmark the permalink.

About The Antiplanner

The Antiplanner is a forester and economist with more than fifty years of experience critiquing government land-use and transportation plans.

2 Responses to Forward into the Past Via VIA

  1. LazyReader says:

    Meanwhile even the LA Times finally admits Governor Browns ambitious plan to save the world ie California’s environment/integrity/reputation is sinking. But they’ll still aching to spend every last dime and dollar Cali has.

    http://www.latimes.com/politics/la-pol-sac-skelton-jerry-brown-agenda-priorities-20160818-snap-story.html

    “Brown has kept it afloat with money generated by his fight against global warming. It involves a cap-and-trade program that controls greenhouse gas emissions. The state peddles permits to pollute and pumps 25% of the profits into high-speed rail.” but didn’t take into consideration the thought that said businesses would remain in California………..

  2. Frank says:

    California? Hahaha. Might as well give it back to the Mexicans to run into the ground, and I love me some Mexicans. I wouldn’t ever live there again, especially with laws that would force me to drive 72 miles from my hometown to buy ammo just so I could to go hunting for birds and deer to feed my family.

    The state is too big. Break it up. What happens in Yreka and Eureka is so far removed from the population center. The State of Jefferson shall succeed (secede)!

    inb4 msetty says “wet dreams”

Leave a Reply