Latest High-Speed Rail Grant

Secretary of Immobility Ray LaHood announced yesterday the latest–and possibly last–round of high-speed rail grants, this one from redistribution of the $2.4 billion rejected by the state of Florida. As the Antiplanner noted in March, LaHood could have given the entire $2.4 billion to California, sending a signal that the administration remains serious about building a true high-speed rail network.

Instead, LaHood gave only $300 million to California high-speed rail, and instead gave the lion’s share–$800 million–to Amtrak and several eastern states for the Northeast Corridor–a corridor that wasn’t even on the original high-speed rail list until LaHood added it in March. Most of the rest of the money went for minor improvements in track to allow trains to run slightly faster than they run today, or for stations, locomotives, passenger cars, and similar facilities that will pretty much operate at conventional speeds.

California expects to use the $300 million to build another 20 miles of rail line in the state’s Central Valley, on top of the 65 miles or so that are already funded. The Central Valley is the least-expensive portion of the planned 420-mile route that includes two mountain crossings and more than 100 miles through urban areas. Since the state has little more than 10 percent of the money it needs to complete the San Francisco-Anaheim route, giving it $300 million is not going to help it complete the project. Yet California politicians claim they are thrilled with the grant.


women viagra australia Speaking about physical therapists, they are the people to look out for. This inefficiency supplementprofessors.com sildenafil professional is popularly known impotency or ED in men, with extremely positive results being experienced by those effected. Use your imagination and see india generic cialis what you can find. Symptoms are often intense and may be sudden in onset but also may be mild and of gradual onset. buy levitra
California also received $68 million to purchase “high-performance” rail cars and “quick-acceleration” locomotives. Despite the hype, this equipment will only slightly increase speeds, if it increases them at all, of existing Amtrak-run trains in California. Illinois, Indiana, Iowa, Michigan, and Missouri received $268 million in grants for similar equipment, but don’t expect to see trains going 220 mph, or even 110 mph, in those states anytime soon.

Some of the money is just for engineering and environmental studies. Minnesota received $15 million for a study of a 110-mph train to Duluth. Texas received $15 million for a study of a high-speed train from Dallas to Houston. Neither of these routes are on the high-speed corridor list, the latter because of lobbying from Southwest Airlines, which offers 25 planes a day between these two cities at fares as low as $49. No doubt the consultants who get the contracts to do these engineering studies will set aside a healthy portion of their profits to lobby for eventual construction of these routes.

LaHood gave out a total of $2.02 billion yesterday, but Florida turned $2.4 billion back to the feds. So the Department of Transportation may have close to another $400 million yet to give away. Don’t expect that $400 million to reignite the fire for high-speed rail.

Tagged . Bookmark the permalink.

About The Antiplanner

The Antiplanner is a forester and economist with more than fifty years of experience critiquing government land-use and transportation plans.

3 Responses to Latest High-Speed Rail Grant

  1. metrosucks says:

    Though, O’Toole, you were given a $50,000 grant to bash transit for Koch.

  2. Andy says:

    If you throw enough federal money at it, Professional Planners will make up reasons to persuade local officials to take the money and burn it.

  3. Andrew says:

    Antiplanner:

    California expects to use the $300 million to build another 20 miles of rail line in the state’s Central Valley, on top of the 65 miles or so that are already funded.

    Actually, about 130+/- miles is now funded according to the FRA press release, or about 50% more than the number you report. California HSR project has $3.9B of the $10B in total grants, and not even half of that will be spent on the Central Valley segment.

    Despite the hype, this equipment will only slightly increase speeds, if it increases them at all, of existing Amtrak-run trains in California. Illinois, Indiana, Iowa, Michigan, and Missouri received $268 million in grants for similar equipment, but don’t expect to see trains going 220 mph, or even 110 mph, in those states anytime soon.

    Actually, as soon as the under construction signal work in Michigan and Indiana is complete, and the under construction trackwork and signal work in Illinois is complete, trains will be running at 110 mph on both the Detroit and St. Louis lines respectively.

    So the Department of Transportation may have close to another $400 million yet to give away.

    No, its gone. The $400M discrepancy is unobligated money that was rescinded as part of the phoney-baloney budget deal for FY2011. Since it was highly unlikely to be spent this year, and since the Ohio, Wisconsin, and Florida rejections produced an unexpected opportunity to effectively award another $3.251B, it was hardly painful to give up $400M of that. In essence, the USDOT gave out $8B from the ARRA Stimulus, $2.5 billion from FY2010 budget, and $2.8B outside of the normal FY2011 budget from rejected money. The rejected monies far exceeded the House amount of $2.5B that had been settled on in the fall of last year, so the USDOT was able to actually give out $300M more than planned as recently as 6 months ago without authorizing any additional revenues thanks to the regressive actions in OH, WI, and FL. The Administration and USDOT will certainly ask for more money in FY2012 and will undoubtedly get $1B+.

    You really should be able to be more accurate in these sort of notes.

Leave a Reply