Trump’s New CAFE Proposal

It is likely that, by the time you read this, the Department of Transportation and Environmental Protection Agency will have made a joint announcement about reforming the corporate average fuel economy (CAFE) standards. Originally adopted in 1978, when new cars were required to average all of 18 miles per gallon, the standards were increased by the Obama administration to a target of 54.5 mpg by 2025. (This 54.5 is actually an idealized number; as a practical matter, the real target for 2025 is about 39 mpg.)

As I am writing this, I don’t know exactly what today’s proposal will be, but an article in yesterday’s Wall Street Journal by DOT secretary Elaine Chao and acting EPA administrator Andrew Wheeler provides some hints. Most important, the article notes that the goal is “to create one national standard.” This means that California won’t be able to impose its own, stronger standards.

As the Competitive Enterprise Institute’s Marlo Lewis observes, when Congress created the CAFE program in 1975, it specially forbade states from adopting their own stronger rules, probably because this would greatly increase the costs of compliance to manufacturers. Despite that, the Obama administration decided to exempt California from the one-national-standard rule. The Trump administration is going back to the actual law. Continue reading

Obamacars to Cost $6,714 More?

Motor Trend magazine reports that meeting President Obama’s fuel-economy standards for 2025 will cost consumers $6,714 more per car. This is based on a paper published by the Center for Automotive Research last June, when Obama’s standards were still in flux.

There is some debate over this conclusion: a group called the International Council on Clean Transportation thinks that CAR has exaggerated the difficulties (CAR’s response). ICCT notes that the auto industry has a history of crying wolf when the federal government proposes new safety or pollution standards: Henry Ford II, for example, predicted that seatbelt and safety glass standards would “close down” his company.

Continue reading

Obama Undercuts Case for HSR and Rail Transit

President Obama has ordered the auto industry to make cars that average 54.5 miles per gallon by 2025. This is after his 2009 order directing the industry to make cars that average 34.5 miles per gallon by 2016.

As a free-market advocate, I should be outraged that Obama is ordering private enterprise around like a petty dictator. But actually I feel schadenfreude for all the anti-auto environmentalists who will now have an even more difficult time claiming we need to invest in transit and intercity trains to save energy.

Continue reading