Bringing the FRA into the Fantasy World

“As in many other arenas, California has taken the lead nationally to advance high-speed rail, starting an economically transformative project in the Central Valley and assuming the challenges that come with that leadership.” That sounds like something someone might have made in 2009 when excitement was building over California’s plan to build a high-speed rail line from Los Angeles to San Francisco. There’s no way anyone would talk like that today given what we know about 100 percent cost overruns, more than a decade of delays, and the inability of California to raise the money to finish more than a fraction of the project.

Yet that statement was made just three months ago by Amit Bose, who President Biden has nominated to lead the Federal Railroad Administration and serve as the administration’s cheerleader for high-speed rail and other passenger rail projects.

Bose’s career clearly demonstrates a faith in big-government spending on transportation projects of little value to travelers or shippers. He worked for New Jersey Transit early in his career, and during the Obama administration he worked closely with Secretary of Immobility Ray LaHood, who firmly believed that 8-mile-per-hour streetcars were better than buses despite the buses’ higher speeds, greater capacities, and lower costs. While at DOT, Bose arranged a $2.5 billion federal “loan” to Amtrak to buy new Acela trains despite knowing that Amtrak is unlikely to ever have the funds to repay such a loan (unless they come from other federal grants).

Does decreased hip angle equal less power?One of the most common cycling positions used by “flexiholics” has the hip flexors locked short and the buy viagra professional hams and glutes overstretched and weak. If you have developed ED, tab sildenafil simply talk to your doctor and then consume medicines. viagra india The treatment is cost-effective, thus get relief in a short span of time. cialis overnight delivery check out address NEVER put a long list into the To or cc fields. Bose spent the Trump years working for HNTB, a consulting firm that makes its money from taxpayer-supported transit projects. It seems likely that HNTB hoped to take advantage of Bose’s inside-view of the DOT in order to get funds for various new projects while Bose earned a fat salary between Democratic administrations.

Most recently, Bose was deputy administrator and acting administrator of the Federal Railroad Administration, so Biden’s nomination merely confirms a decision that had apparently already been made. The FRA’s most important job is ensuring railroad safety: according to its 2020 budget, 920 of its 932 staffers worked on “safety and operations” while just 12 worked on Amtrak and high-speed rail. But Bose and Biden clearly live in the same fantasy world where the intercity passenger trains that carry just 0.1 percent of passenger travel are somehow vitally important and high-speed trains that require heavy subsidies to compete with automobiles and buses over short distances and airliners over long distances are somehow the transportation of the future.

Tagged , . Bookmark the permalink.

About The Antiplanner

The Antiplanner is a forester and economist with more than fifty years of experience critiquing government land-use and transportation plans.

2 Responses to Bringing the FRA into the Fantasy World

  1. metrosucks says:

    Speaking of fantasy world, apparently the real solution to congestion on I-90 and SR18 up here in Seattle is to rebuild and modernize Stampede Pass.

    https://www.theurbanist.org/2021/05/06/skip-freeway-expansions-rebuild-stampede-pass/?amp

  2. Ike says:

    It would be great if you have a chance to do an article on the Altamont Corridor Express [ACE] extension into California’s central valley. I read the EIR over the weekend and it seems another greatly exaggerated pipe dream. Also I would love to share some hard data with our local elected officials on what a waste this will be and the claimed benefits have no change of materializing.

    https://acerail.com/ace-ceres-merced-deir/

Leave a Reply