Gondola: Thy Name Is Boondoggle

As if we need any more evidence of profligate waste in the transit industry, Chicago, Austin, and other cities are considering aerial trams, also known as gondolas. Portland’s infamous aerial tram, which opened in 2006, cost 500 percent more than the original projection, carries a mere 3,200 round trips per day, and collects fares that cover just 22 percent of its operating costs. The economic development that was promised if Portland taxpayers helped build it went to Florida instead.

Given this terrible track record, it’s not surprising that other cities weren’t lining up to follow Portland’s example in building aerial trams. So what’s changed to get cities interested in them again? According to Bloomberg, it is lobbying by ski lift manufacturers. They’ve somehow managed to convince people in Austin that a tram will reduce congestion and people in Chicago that a tram will attract tourists, even though Portland’s tram has done neither.

Disneyland used to have an aerial tram, but Disney shut it down in the 1990s “citing its lack of popularity and the number of workers required to operate it.” Such factors tend to be ignored by transit agencies, which merely cut popular routes to pay for unpopular ones and draw upon tax dollars to pay workers.

The erect state of penile organ remains strong for 4 to 6 cialis cipla hours, without producing any complications so that lovemaking can be conducted as desired. In addition to this, the condition has been so common that can be noticed in purchase generic cialis a many man when they come to know about their erectile issues. A chronic deficiency in vitamin B12 might http://new.castillodeprincesas.com/directorio/seccion/recordatorios/ viagra without prescription lead to erectile dysfunction. There have been a large number of males live the stereotype that viagra online they won’t be able enjoying sexual life to the fullest. It is this attitude that has made transit one of the least productive industries in the country. According to the historical tables in the American Public Transportation Association Transit Fact Book, the number of passengers carried per operating worker has declined by 56 percent since 1960, when the transit industry was mostly private. The Fact Book doesn’t list capital workers before 1984, but since then the number of passengers carried per capital worker has declined by 25 percent.

The industry’s obsession with expensive and unproductive forms of transit is one of the reasons for this decline. According to APTA’s data, bus rapid transit in 2014 produced 12 percent more fare revenues and 64 percent more riders per operating employee than light rail. Add capital employees and the difference would be even greater. Yet many cities want to build light rail partly because of the mistaken belief that it carries more riders per worker. Light rail may carry more riders per driver than buses, but drivers make up only a tiny fraction of the number of employees required to keep a light-rail line going.

Rail transit is inferior to buses because of its inflexibility. Aerial trams are even more inflexible because, once built, it is extremely difficult to add capacity. At least with rail lines, agencies can run more trains per hour until they reach capacity–and few outside of New York and Washington are close to capacity–but that can’t easily be done with aerial trams.

A boondoggle by any other name would smell as foul, and aerial tram, thy name is boondoggle. Taxpayers will have to hope that no one takes this idea too seriously.

Tagged . Bookmark the permalink.

About The Antiplanner

The Antiplanner is a forester and economist with more than fifty years of experience critiquing government land-use and transportation plans.

7 Responses to Gondola: Thy Name Is Boondoggle

  1. irandom says:

    It’s a lot of fun to be swung around like a pinata in the wind, but my mom wasn’t too thrilled by it.

  2. OFP2003 says:

    Don’t forget the safety record of the “sky lifts” Texas has had a few:
    http://www3.gendisasters.com/texas/18751/dallas-tx-state-fair-sky-ride-crash-oct-1979
    Also I think there was a death on the San Antonio Monorail also:
    http://www3.gendisasters.com/texas/18805/san-antonio-tx-hemisfair-monorail-accident-sep-1968
    Whatever happened to the “Monorail Craze” anyway? Or, I guess an even better question might be: “Why was there a “Monorail Craze” in the first place???

  3. LazyReader says:

    For one aerial trams are a legitimate form of transportation………..ON A MOUNTAIN!
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nDIRDt3eGRs

  4. JOHN1000 says:

    When a bus has a flat tire, no real problem. When a train gets stuck in a tunnel – bad but liveable.
    When a tram has a problem – yikes.
    Remember in 2006, two NYC trams got stuck and people were left hanging in the air for many hours. The news coverage was non stop all night and into the early morning. Their new regulations require: “in case of an emergency, each car now is equipped with blankets, water, food, and a toilet with a privacy curtain.” That makes me feel much safer…….

  5. Dave Brough says:

    Of the tens of thousands of cable propelled transport (CPT) systems installed world-wide, most are associated with ski resorts where they operate one quarter of the year and for a third of each day only carry their passengers for half the trip. If they can operate there, surely they can operate anywhere.
    Not mentioned by the Antiplanner: They are ultra safe, zero emission, can be quickly installed (typically, less than a year), have virtually no surface impact and provide pax with views, thus now making them ideal tourist attractions. To equal the capacity of a single modern gondola would would take several hundred buses. https://www.doppelmayr.com/en/applications/urban/urban-brochure/
    I suggest that most of the cost increases occur, not because of the technology, but because certain public people want to get their names on a brass plaque and will thus build the fanciest system money can buy.
    Gondolas have their downsides, but they and other aerial technologies have earned their place in the urban environment.

  6. Not Sure says:

    “They are … zero emission…”

    Powered by unicorn farts, or what?

  7. Frank says:

    “Gondolas have their downsides, but they and other aerial technologies have earned their place in the urban environment.”

    Yes, They have earned their place by not paying their own way. Riiiiiiiight.

Leave a Reply