Search Results for: rail projects

Is Amtrak Guilty of Securities Fraud?

If Amtrak were a public corporation rather than a government-owned entity, a recent press release and other public statements by Amtrak officials would be considered securities fraud. According to the press release issued last week, fiscal year 2019 was Amtrak’s best year ever. The release claimed that operating revenues covered 99.1 percent of its operating costs, and Amtrak officials are so optimistic about the future that they predict the company will actually earn a profit next year.

Click image to download a three-page PDF of this policy brief.

Amtrak made these statements before it released its annual financial report (which is still not available), substituting instead an infographic. Moreover, the press release deliberately misrepresented the information that will eventually be published in that financial statement. Amtrak is counting on the fact that far fewer people will read the financial statement than the press release or news reports about that release. Continue reading

Planning for an Unattainable Fantasy

Austin is one of the fastest-growing cities in America, and the city of Austin and Austin’s transit agency, Capital Metro, have a plan for dealing with all of the traffic that will be generated by that growth: assume that a third of the people who now drive alone to work will switch to transit, bicycling, walking, or telecommuting by 2039. That’s right up there with planning for dinner by assuming that food will magically appear on the table the same way it does in Hogwarts.


Click image to download a 4-page PDF of this policy brief.

Austin planners say that 74 percent of Austin workers drive alone to their jobs. In this, they are already behind the times, as the 2018 American Community Survey found that 75.4 percent of Austin workers drove alone (that’s for the city of Austin; the drive-alone share in the the Austin urban area was 77.0 percent). The 2018 survey was released only a month before Austin’s latest planning document, but even the 2017 survey found that 75 percent of Austin workers drove alone. You have to go back to the 2016 survey to find 74 percent drive-alones. So while Austin planners are assuming they can reduce driving alone from 74 to 50 percent, it is actually moving in the other direction. Continue reading

Amtrak Inspector General Clueless

Amtrak’s inspector general issued a report last week that reveals an utter cluelessness about Amtrak and how it works. The report argues that late trains are costing Amtrak revenues and that, instead of trying to run the trains on time, Amtrak should spend some of its precious resources building a computer model to estimate how many riders it loses for each late train.

The report, titled Better Estimates Needed of the Financial Impacts of Poor On-Time Performance, devotes many of its pages to building such a model itself and concludes that improving on-time performance by 5 percent could increase revenues by $12 million. Since Amtrak’s 2018 operating losses are $171 million, says the report, such an improvement could significantly reduce those losses. Continue reading

How New Starts Harms Transit Riders

Rail transit lines built with federal support have done more harm than good to transit riders and urban transportation systems as a whole. Too often, the high cost of rail has forced transit agencies to cut bus service and raise fares. In the worst cases, the systems lost more bus riders than they gain rail riders. In most other cases, per capita ridership and/or transit’s share of commuting declined. These regions and transit systems would have been better off without the federal government enticing them into build rail transit.

Click image to download a 6-page PDF of this policy brief.

A little over a century ago, more than a thousand American cities, including every city with more than 15,000 people, had some form of rail transit. Then, in 1927, the first buses were produced that cost less both to buy and to operate than rail transit. By then, many of the rail lines built in the nineteenth century were wearing out, so transit riders appreciated the buses because they were faster and more comfortable than the railcars and could easily take on new routes. Buses can also move more people per hour than almost any rail line because buses, though having lower capacities per vehicle, can safely operate far more frequently than rail lines. Continue reading

Transport Costs & Subsidies by Mode

Supporters of increased subsidies to urban transit and intercity passenger trains often argue that all transportation is subsidized, so it’s only fair that transit and Amtrak should also be subsidized. While it’s true that most transportation is subsidized, it is worth looking at the extent of those subsidies to judge whether subsidies to some forms of transport should be increased or reduced.

Click image to download a four-page PDF of this policy brief.

Americans spent about $1.3 trillion of their personal incomes on transportation in 2017 (based on the Bureau of Economic Analysis’ National Income and Product Accounts (NIPA) table 2.5.5, lines 53 and 116). On top of this, transportation received about $200 billion in subsidies from federal, state, and local governments (based on subtracting total government expenditures on transport from total government revenues from transport). Continue reading

Congestion Is a Problem, Not a Solution

Phoenix has seen the least increase in congestion of any major urban area in America. According to the data set accompanying the Texas Transportation Institute’s recently released 2019 Urban Mobility Report, the average commuter in Phoenix suffered from 80 hours of delay in 2017, up 26 hours from 1982. That compares with an 82-hour growth in delay per commuter in the San Francisco and Washington urban areas and an average 53-hour increase in delay for the nation’s top 50 urban areas.[*]

Click image to download a four-page PDF of this policy brief.

Phoenix’s relatively small increase in traffic congestion is largely due to the massive increase in freeways in the region. According to an earlier edition of the urban mobility report, Phoenix had 210 lane-miles of freeways in 1982, growing to 2,015 by 2017. Part of this increase was due to an expansion of the urban area, leading to the addition of freeways that already existed but were previously outside the urban area. But the region has little more than doubled in land area since 1982 while the freeway lane-miles increased by nearly ten times. No other region has seen such a large increase in freeway lane-miles. Continue reading

Solving the Amtrak Conundrum

Amtrak is a conundrum that has been difficult for both politicians and Amtrak managers to solve.

Click image to download a four-page PDF of this policy brief.

  • Politicians and the media act as if it is an important mode of travel, yet it carries less than 1 percent as many passenger miles as domestic airlines and just 0.1 percent of total domestic passenger miles.
  • Rail advocates claim intercity passenger trains are economically competitive, yet Amtrak fares per passenger mile average nearly three times airline fares, and when subsidies are added Amtrak costs four times as much per passenger mile as the airlines and well over twice as much as driving.
  • Amtrak claims that some of its trains earn a profit and overall passenger revenues cover 95 percent of its costs, yet even the Rail Passengers Association, the leading supporter of intercity passenger trains, believes Amtrak’s accounting methods misrepresent reality.

It will surprise you to discover prescription de levitra the strength you cultivate within as you hold to being true to yourself. Men usually do not react much but when they do it through the purchase cheap cialis power of intention. Under normal circumstances, endometrial covered on cialis side effects uterine cavity surface. Take in of cialis online from india should be regarded as food as opposed to supplements. Continue reading

Eight Reasons to Kill New Starts

Since 1992, federal taxpayers have helped fund construction of urban rail transit lines through a program called New Starts. This program is due to expire in 2020, and tomorrow, the Highways and Transit Subcommittee of the House Transportation and Infrastructure Committee will hold a hearing on whether or not to renew it.

No doubt most of the witnesses at the hearing will be transit agency officials bragging about how their expensive projects have created jobs and generated economic development. But a close look at the projects built with this fund reveals that New Starts has done more damage to American cities than any other federal program since the urban renewal projects of the 1950s. Here are eight reasons why Congress should not renew the program.

1. New Starts encourages cities to waste money. The more expensive the project, the more money New Starts provides, so transit agencies plan increasingly expensive projects to get “their share” of the money. As a result, average light-rail construction costs have exploded from under $17 million per mile (in today’s dollars) in 1981 to more than $220 million a mile today. Continue reading

Antiplanner Policy Briefs

Policy briefs are two- to six-page in-depth analyses of important land-use and transportation issues. These were originally called Transportation Policy Briefs. Because they don’t all deal with transportation, starting with number 6 they are called Antiplanner Policy Briefs.

To make it easier to find policy briefs on specific topics, you can sort by topic. Topics include Automobiles, Government, High-Speed Rail, Highways, Housing, Intercity Passenger Trains, Natural Resources, Regional Planning, Transit, and Transportation. Some briefs cover more than one of these but only the dominant topic is listed for each brief.

#HTMLPDFTopic
150Toward Global Peace & ProsperityGovernment
149The Automobile WonAutomobiles
148Transit's Zombie FutureTransit
147America's Two Housing MarketsHousing
146America's Volatile Housing MarketsHousing
145Property Rights and the New FeudalismHousing
144Americans Fleeing Dense Cities & SuburbsRegional Planning
143Old Technologies for New StartsTransit
142The Myth of Rail MobilityIntercity Passenger Trains
141Airlines: Our #2 Source of MobilityTransportation
140A Century-Old Love of Rail MonopoliesIntercity Passenger Trains
139Traffic Safety: A Matter of DesignHighways
138Transit Crime Rates on the RiseTransit
137State and Local Highway Subsidies in 2019 and 2020Highways
136Truckers, Congestion, and Class ConflictHighways
1352021: The Year Transit Failed to RecoverTransit
134America's Rising Housing PricesHousing
133How Cato Sold Out California Property OwnersHousing
132Boulder's Open Spaces and the Marshall FireNatural Resources
131Killed by the Pandemic: The Virginia Railway ExpressTransit
130U.S. Road Conditions and Performance in 2020Highways
129Why U.S. Infrastructure Is So ExpensiveTransportation
128Sutton Mountain Wilderness Yes, Monument NoNatural Resources
127The Midwest Rail Plan: A Disaster in the MakingHigh-Speed Rail
126Mobility Principles for a Prosperous WorldTransportation
125Transit 2020: The First Year of the PandemicTransit
124A Data-Driven Approach to Transportation SafetyHighways
123The Affordable-Housing Industrial ComplexHousing
122The Truth About Western WildfireNatural Resources
121The Morality of Protecting Endangered SpeciesNatural Resources
120Addressing Droughts with Water MarketsNatural Resources
119Regional Transportation Planning After COVIDRegional Planning
118China's Red Lines: A Failure of Central PlanningHousing
117Giving Transit Its Due PriorityTransit
116Charting Transit Values and TrendsTransit
115Moving the Overton WindowGovernment
114The World's Finest RailroadsTransportation
113The Failure of Transit in the Post-COVID EraTransit
112Moving from Transit Apartheid to Transportation EquityTransit
111Cost Overruns and Ridership ShortfallsTransit
110The War on Cars and Delays to Emergency ResponseHighways
109Reinventing Transit for a Post-COVID WorldTransit
108Housing Affordability from 1950 Through 2019Housing
107How San Jose Held Up Google for $200 MillionRegional Planning
106Jane Jacobs and the Mid-Rise ManiaRegional Planning
105Does Transit Cost Effectively Help Low-Income People?Transit
104San Diego's Insane $163.5 Billion PlanRegional Planning
103$85 Billion for Empty Buses and RailcarsTransit
102The Case Against AmtrakIntercity Passenger Trains
101Restoring Trust to the Highway Trust FundHighways
100Making Massachusetts Housing AffordableHousing
99Can America's Power Plants Support Electric Vehicles?Automobiles
98Amtrak Can't Connect UsIntercity Passenger Trains
97Miami Affordable Housing ViceHousing
96Mileage-Based User Fees for Highway FinanceHighways
95Housing Affordability and the PandemicHousing
94Applying Value Engineering to Transit ProjectsTransit
93Should Seattle Aspire to Grow to 2 Million People?Housing
92Japan's Addiction: The Dark Side of the Bullet TrainsHigh-Speed Rail
91Using the Law of Large Proportions to Save EnergyAutomobiles
90Are Accidents of History Irreversible?Intercity Passenger Trains
89Transit 2020: Subsidies Up, Ridership DownTransit
88Increasing Safety, Improving the EconomyHighways
87Americans Are on the MoveHousing
86How Much Is a Trillion Dollars?Government
85Transit: Browner Than EverTransit
84Supercommuting and Marchetti’s ConstantHighways
83Closing the China-US Freeway GapHighways
82Ten Reasons Why Transit Parity Is a Bad IdeaTransit
81What Infrastructure Crisis? Highways & Bridges Are FineHighways
80How Transit Subsidies Harm Low-Income PeopleTransit
79The Obscure Origins of the Deep StateGovernment
78Conventional Buses: Transit's 93-Year-Old TechnologyTransit
77Transit's Diminishing Returns in 2019Transit
7610 Reasons Not to Build High-Speed Rail in the U.S.High-Speed Rail
75BLM: Following the MoneyNatural Resources
74High-Capacity Transit DeceptionsTransit
73New Transit Lines Won't Relieve CongestionTransit
72The Affordable Housing ScamHousing
71Recent and Long-Term Housing TrendsHousing
70The Last Pre-Pandemic Snapshot of the USATransportation
69Transit and the Mania for DensityHousing
68Rapid Bus: Finding the Right ModelTransit
67The Streetcar Intelligence TestTransit
66Which Rapid-Transit Lines Should Be Replaced with Buses?Transit
65The Transit-Industrial ComplexTransit
64Why the Hyperloop Will FailHigh-Speed Rail
63Why Trump Should Veto the Great American Outdoors ActNatural Resources
62SunFail: Orlando's Commuter-Rail DisasterTransit
61High-Speed Rail: Yesterday's Transportation TomorrowHigh-Speed Rail
60The Mystery of the Missing Motorcoach MilesTransportation
59Selling Federal Assets to Pay the National DebtNatural Resources
58To Densify or Not to Densify: The Debate ContinuesHousing
57Demand the Right to Pay for Your Own Transportation!Transportation
56Transit Lost 84 Percent of Riders in AprilTransit
55The Hubris of Central PlannersGovernment
54Reducing Poverty by Increasing Auto OwnershipAutomobiles
53Transportation After the PandemicTransportation
52The Rise and Fall of Downtown USARegional Planning
51The Virtues of Autos and SuburbsAutomobiles
50The MCU School of Transportation PlanningTransportation
49Class, Not Race, Is the Issue in the PandemicGovernment
48What Were They Thinking? Post-1980 Commuter TrainsTransit
47Transportation Resiliency in a World of Black SwansTransportation
46Light Rail DisastersTransit
45Dude, Where's My Driverless Car?Automobiles
44The Induced-Demand ConHighways
43The Futility of Trying to Reduce DrivingAutomobiles
42TriMet Compounding 40 Years of Bad DecisionsTransit
41A Critique of L.A. Metro's 28 by 2028 PlanTransit
40Time to End State & Local Highway SubsidiesHighways
392019 Ridership Numbers Reveal Transit's Dim FutureTransit
38Seattle's Anti-Auto Policies Hurt the PoorAutomobiles
37Honolulu's Terrible Folly and a Transit MysteryTransit
36Make America Affordable Again by Ending the New FeudalismHousing
35Transit Capital vs. Operating CostsTransit
3427 Quintillion Transit ChartsTransit
33Urban Transit Is an Energy HogTransit
32Costs Up, Riders Down: 2018 Transit DatabaseTransit
31A Tale of Three Private High-Speed Rail PlansHigh-Speed Rail
30Does Capital Spending Boost Transit Ridership?Transit
29Reducing Mobility to Boost TransitTransit
28Is Amtrak Guilty of Securities Fraud?Intercity Passenger Trains
27Transportation Planning for an Unattainable FantasyTransportation
26Scapegoating Ride Hailing to Justify Transit SubsidiesTransit
25Making Cities Safe for Pedestrians and CyclistsHighways
24The Case for Single-Family NeighborhoodsHousing
23Home Prices in Growth-Restricted Areas Rise HigherHousing
222018 Census Data Show Transit in DeclineTransit
21How the New Starts Fund Harms Transit RidersTransit
20Transportation Costs & Subsidies by ModeTransportation
19Congestion Is a Problem, Not a SolutionHighways
18Countering the Forest Service Fire NarrativeNatural Resources
17Debunking the Fake Farmland CrisisRegional Planning
16Should the U.S. Be More Like Europe?Transportation
15Transit Ridership Falls Another 2.9% in JuneTransit
14Solving the Amtrak ConundrumIntercity Passenger Trains
13Front Range Commuter Rail Is a Terrible IdeaTransit
12No One Forced Americans to DriveAutomobiles
11Does Rail Transit Generate Economic Development?Transit
10Los Angeles Metro’s New Climate StrategyTransit
9The Best Are None Too Good: Ranking Transit AgenciesTransit
8Reports from the Front Lines in the War on HomeownershipHousing
7Thanks to New York, April Transit Ridership Grew by 2%Transit
61,080 Transit Charts in a Single SpreadsheetTransit
5How Vital Is Transit In Your Region? Part 2: DOT DataTransit
4How Vital Is Transit In Your Region? Part 1: Census DataTransit
3Transit Death Spiral: First Quarter Ridership Down 2.6%Transit
2A Tale of Two Train Disasters: FasTracks & California High-Speed RailHigh-Speed Rail
1Transit’s Growing Costs Drive Away Low-Income CommutersTransit

11. A Few Cases

Growing up in Portland, I was taught that the city had the cleanest water in the world because it came from a watershed on the Mount Hood National Forest that had been set aside exclusively for Portland’s use. The Bull Run Trespass Act of 1904 closed the 102-square-mile Bull Run Watershed, along with a 41-square-mile buffer around it, to all public entry, and only Forest Service officials and employees of the Portland water bureau were allowed to enter the area.

This belief was so well known that a medical doctor named Joseph Miller bought a piece of land on the edge of the buffer strip and built a home. There he and his wife lived for many years, content in the knowledge that behind their house was 143 square miles of pristine wilderness that, unlike most wilderness, wasn’t even open to public recreation.

I was in Corvallis studying forestry when this myth came tumbling down in the form of a landslide in 1971. Portlanders woke up one morning to find their “pristine” water to be muddy brown, and they were advised to boil it before drinking it (as if anyone would want to drink brown water). The Forest Service hastened to announce that the landslide that had polluted the city’s water wasn’t caused by one of the clearcuts in the watershed. What it didn’t say was that the landslide was caused by a road leading to one of those clearcuts. Continue reading